Book Review: Wallflower Most Wanted by Manda Collins

Publication date:January 30, 2018

I received a copy of this novel in exchange for an honest review.


In this third installment of the Studies in Scandal series, Sophia Hastings, artist and unapologetic bluestocking, excels in both art theory as well as producing stellar paintings  of her own, works which at times make her the center of controversy. She finds an ardent supporter in Lord Benedict Lisle, second son of the Duke of Pemberton and newly appointed vicar of Little Seaford. When Sophia and Ben are thrown into an art forgery mystery, the two discover much more than the identity of the forgers.

I’m a huge fan of this series, but I wasn’t a huge fan of this one. The concept of a series relaying the trials of four would-be heiresses and celebrating their accomplishments in male-dominated fields is refreshing. These are no damsels in distress. They know their minds and go after what they want. Each has been tasked with a decidedly un-female job, and this novel is no exception, but I wasn’t as entertained by Sophia as I was with the other two heroines. She just didn’t seem to have the depth of Ivy (Book One) and Daphne (Book Two), and the book lacked some of the humor as the first two. She’s an artist with two paintings that are causing a stir in a local art exhibition–that’s about it. Reminders of her extreme beauty became tedious as did the slow pacing of the mystery. By the end, I didn’t really care to discover the forgers because I didn’t feel vested in the search as I had in the first two.

The one truly exceptional part of this novel is the hero. Ben’s role as local vicar created a non typical  character for a romance novel. He had some of the normal traits–handsome and wanted by every girl, check; crazy-rich aristocrat, check; big heart for the socially downtrodden, check. But his concern for propriety and “wait for her to make the first move” attitude were completely different. He was sweet-little too sweet for me. I like a do gooder as much as the next gal, but I just wanted to see him lose his constant cool. I needed more fire, more pizzazz. So while he was definitely different, I’m nonplussed. He seemed too weak to carry the role as hero.

In short, I’ll continue to lie Manda Collins, and I’ll most assuredly be on the lookout for her next novel, but this one was just okay for me.


3 stars


Comments are closed.